Pies

We’ve recently received feedback from our customers regarding the range of pies we are offering in the later hours of the evening. We would like to respond to the feedback we have received & assist our customers in having as quick and easy an ordering experience as possible.

Due to baking our pies fresh, we bake based on the quantity of orders we expect to receive. We do this to ensure we aren’t baking either too few pies, nor too many. During the day, this means stocking each pie & baking fresh as we sell, but in the evenings, because we do not receive a consistent number of orders, we do not bake every pie available, which means we will not be stocking our full range of pies at all hours of the evening.

There is an easy solution however, so don’t worry, you can always get any Pie or Pastry that you are craving, baked fresh! If you would like to order any number of Fresh Pies or Pastries in the evening, all you have to do, is call ten minutes before your arrival, so we can have a head start on baking the pies and there will be no wait for you once you reach our drive thru. 

0422 635 779

There’s something extra special about My Pie, it comes from the mind and hands of a master baker. With the help of our off-site bakery, we are able to bake fresh pies on-site, every day, all from the comfort of our compact kitchen! Our pies are never frozen, so our fresh pastry will always be perfectly crisp, buttery and flaky with piping-hot fillings that are bursting with flavor. 

When developing our menu, we worked very closely with our bakers to create the best selection of pies possible. We’re always trying to keep up with what our customers want, so when we saw that our loyal regulars were after some more comfort food, we were back in the bakery that day to prepare our Shepherd’s Pie, which we launched less than three months after opening our doors! We’re always looking out for you, so if there’s something you reckon we should be providing, make sure to sound off and let us know!

We constantly hear from our customers their surprise at how different our pies are from mass-produced servo pies that have been reheated from frozen. Our pies are so delicious, people were asking to take packs home to enjoy later, so we had to oblige!